Pietenpol-List: from the archives on brazing
Posted: Wed Jun 25, 2003 11:23 am
Original Posted By: "Gary McNeel, Jr."
Gene,We have been over this before in the archives. This is from the archives:I will quote from Performance Welding by Richard Finch who is an expert inwelding, is in the aerospace industry, and wrote the parts of AC 43-1Brelating to welding. He says, and I quote without permission:"Brazing SteelAlways avoid brazing 4130 steel. The reason to not braze chromemoly isthat the steel has a definite grain structure that actually opens up atmedium red brazing temperatures. When brazing alloy is melted onto thesteel surface, it flows easily into the many small cracks and crevices inthe chromemoly steeel. Then as the braze joint cools, the brass will notcompress and it forces MAJOR cracks to form in the 4130 steel. Often, abrazed 4130 steel part will crack completely in two before your eyes as itcools.Mild steel (1020, 1025, and so on) is ready made forbrazing..........Brazing, when done correctly, can last as long as anyother metal-joining method. And it can be as strong as fusion welding whenit is done correctly."________________________________________________________________________________Date: Wed, 25 Jun 2003 12:44:25 -0400
Gene,We have been over this before in the archives. This is from the archives:I will quote from Performance Welding by Richard Finch who is an expert inwelding, is in the aerospace industry, and wrote the parts of AC 43-1Brelating to welding. He says, and I quote without permission:"Brazing SteelAlways avoid brazing 4130 steel. The reason to not braze chromemoly isthat the steel has a definite grain structure that actually opens up atmedium red brazing temperatures. When brazing alloy is melted onto thesteel surface, it flows easily into the many small cracks and crevices inthe chromemoly steeel. Then as the braze joint cools, the brass will notcompress and it forces MAJOR cracks to form in the 4130 steel. Often, abrazed 4130 steel part will crack completely in two before your eyes as itcools.Mild steel (1020, 1025, and so on) is ready made forbrazing..........Brazing, when done correctly, can last as long as anyother metal-joining method. And it can be as strong as fusion welding whenit is done correctly."________________________________________________________________________________Date: Wed, 25 Jun 2003 12:44:25 -0400